Compassionate Utilization of the POLST Form
Listening through fear, disagreement, and uncertainty so POLST choices reflect the person receiving care.
Pay attention to how the conversation feels
A POLST form can be completed correctly while the patient still feels unheard. A person may agree because everyone seems to be waiting, because a relative is answering for them, or because they believe there is a preferred answer. Hospice nurses are often well placed to notice that hesitation and make room for the patient’s voice.
Before asking the next question, consider what is happening in the room. Is the patient uncomfortable? Can they hear? Have they had time to respond? Are we speaking to the patient or only about the patient? A simple pause—“I want to make sure we are hearing what you want”—can change the direction of the encounter.
Compassionate use of POLST means helping the patient understand the choices and supporting an informed decision. It does not mean persuading everyone toward DNR or assuming that a hospice nurse’s personal preference should become the patient’s order. The AHA emphasizes shared decision-making and attention to bias and communication barriers.[1]
Let the form follow the relationship
California POLST is voluntary and intended for people with serious illness or advanced frailty. It complements an advance directive and translates preferences into medical orders.[2] Explain that purpose in ordinary language, then ask what the patient wants to know before proceeding.
Our practical approach moves from Box D, concerning information and the decision-maker, through Box C, artificial nutrition, and Box B, medical interventions, to Box A, CPR. The conversation guide describes this bottom-to-top approach. It is a clinical conversational preference, not a mandatory sequence.
If the patient raises a fear that does not fit the next box, stay with the concern. “I do not want to be alone” may tell you more about what matters than an immediate answer about hospitalization. Explore it, communicate it to the team, and then connect the treatment discussion to the person’s priorities.
Ask what the words mean to this person
Before discussing Box A, ask, “What have you heard about resuscitation?” or “What do you imagine happens when someone receives CPR?” These questions invite understanding without implying that the patient should already know medical terminology.
Explain the treatment and its possible outcomes in manageable pieces. Then ask the patient to describe what they have understood. If they say, “You would help me breathe and I would wake up,” clarify the uncertainty and the distinction between restarting circulation and recovering. Bring patient-specific prognosis questions to the responsible clinician.
A quick “whatever you think” should prompt gentle exploration. The patient may want a recommendation, may be exhausted, or may not understand the decision. Ask, “Would it help to hear the clinician’s recommendation, or is there something we should explain differently first?” Respect a patient’s preferred decision-making style without mistaking disengagement for informed consent.
Respond to emotion before adding another explanation
A patient may become tearful. A son may look away or respond sharply. Do not assume you know the emotion or its cause. You can say, “This seems difficult to talk about. What is on your mind?” Then allow enough time for an answer.
VitalTalk offers approaches for recognizing emotion, showing respect, and exploring concerns; Ariadne Labs provides a structure for conversations about understanding and priorities.[3][4] Use these resources to practice attentive communication rather than memorizing a performance of empathy.
Sometimes the most helpful response is a specific acknowledgment: “You have been trying to make sure she gets good care, and this decision feels heavy.” Avoid saying that you know exactly how someone feels. If a family member shares a prior distressing experience, ask what they need the team to understand about it before returning to the form.
Make “additional orders” a meaningful conversation
In Box C, asking only “Do you have additional orders?” may leave the patient unsure what is being asked. Explain that this is an opportunity to clarify relevant preferences about artificial nutrition. Ask, “If we considered a feeding tube, what would you want it to help you achieve?”
Explore whether a trial would fit the patient’s goals and what would lead them to want reassessment. Ask about dietary needs and any concerns the team has not yet addressed. The clinician should translate appropriate preferences into clear orders; the patient should not be expected to write a medical plan unaided.
If a family says, “We could never stop feeding her,” acknowledge the care behind the statement. Discuss what assistance and comfort care would continue and how feeding decisions relate to the illness. The evidence article distinguishes advanced dementia from conditions with different recovery potential. Avoid a generic explanation that treats every swallowing problem the same.
Separate DNR from the rest of the care plan
DNR addresses resuscitation after arrest. California POLST allows DNR with Full Treatment before arrest. Comfort measures belong in every treatment category. Comfort-Focused Treatment is not itself hospice enrollment and does not automatically prohibit transfer when another setting is needed to relieve distress.[2]
Check the family’s understanding with a practical question: “If he became uncomfortable or developed a new problem, what do you understand the team would do?” If the answer is “nothing, because he is DNR,” return to the explanation. The patient should not be left believing that a resuscitation choice withdraws the team’s attention.
Also avoid promising every requested intervention. If a choice raises concerns about medical effectiveness or consistency with the patient’s goals, involve the responsible clinician. Be clear about the concern while continuing to listen. A respectful conversation can include a clinical recommendation and disagreement.
When the family disagrees
A relative may ask for treatment that a patient with decision-making capacity has declined. Keep the patient’s wishes central and ask what the relative fears will happen. They may be worried about abandonment, suffering, or later regret. Address those concerns without allowing them to erase the patient’s decision.
When the patient cannot make the decision, clarify the authorized surrogate and explore the patient’s known wishes. Ask, “What has she told you about situations like this?” If there is no clear prior statement, help the team understand the patient’s values and interests rather than asking which family member has the strongest preference.
You do not need to resolve a persistent conflict alone. Arrange further discussion with the clinician and appropriate interdisciplinary or ethics support. Describe the disagreement accurately, identify what is needed next, and continue care under current valid orders and applicable procedures. Do not present silence or the end of a meeting as agreement.
Make a trial clear without making it a countdown
When a time-limited trial is clinically appropriate and consistent with the patient’s preferences, specify the intervention, intended benefit, and reassessment plan with the responsible clinician. Ask the family what they understand the trial to mean. They may believe that beginning treatment commits them to it permanently or guarantees improvement.
Explain that reassessment considers what has happened and what the patient would value. A date on the calendar should prompt a clinical conversation, not an unexplained automatic change in care. Document who will review the response, what questions will be considered, and how the family will be included.
Finish with understanding, access, and permission to revisit
Before completion, summarize the choices in relation to what the patient told you. Ask whether the summary sounds right. Obtain the required signatures through the appropriate process; the California provider signature requires a treating physician, NP, or PA. An RN’s valuable discussion does not substitute for that signature.[2]
Ensure that the orders are accessible to the patient and care teams and that important changes are communicated. California guidance allows patients to modify or revoke POLST and identifies exceptions involving invalid or medically ineffective orders.[2] Seek appropriate clinical review when the form and the situation appear inconsistent.
Close with an invitation that does not pressure the patient: “If something about these choices no longer feels right, please tell us so we can talk again.” A form can record a decision at one point in time. The nurse’s continuing attention helps the care remain connected to the person as circumstances change.