POLST: How to Start the Conversation
A compassionate, bottom-to-top POLST conversation, with bedside questions and practical guidance for hospice nurses.
The conversation begins before the form
A patient may become quiet when you bring out a POLST form. A daughter may ask, “Are you saying there is nothing else you can do?” Before explaining the boxes, find out what they have heard and what they are worried about. The nurse’s calm presence can make this feel like a conversation about care rather than a request to sign away care.
You might begin, “I would like to understand what you would want us to do if you became more ill. Is this a comfortable time to talk, or should we first address what is bothering you now?” Attend to pain, breathlessness, fatigue, hearing needs, and language access. A person struggling to participate may need support, a shorter discussion, or another visit.
Introduce California POLST as Physician Orders for Life-Sustaining Treatment: voluntary medical orders intended for serious illness or advanced frailty. It complements an advance directive; it does not appoint a healthcare agent. There is no fixed five-year prognosis requirement.[2] Explain that the purpose is to understand the patient’s choices, including choices for life-prolonging treatment.
The nurse helps make preferences understandable and actionable
Hospice nurses often hear the concerns that patients have not yet raised with a prescriber. You can help explore values, clarify questions, and communicate what remains unresolved. Work within your role and training. In California, the provider signature comes from a treating physician, NP, or PA; an RN discussion alone does not create a valid medical order.[2]
Before the discussion, review existing documents and the team’s clinical assessment. Know whom to contact for prognosis questions, treatment recommendations, or conflicting instructions. You should not have to improvise answers about an intervention’s likely benefit. Tell the family when a question needs further clinical review and make sure someone follows through.
Communication resources from VitalTalk and Ariadne Labs support asking about understanding, making space for emotion, and discussing priorities before recommendations.[3][4] The sample questions below are practical examples to adapt, not a script to complete at the patient’s expense.
Start at the bottom: Box D → Box C → Box B → Box A
The form places CPR first so that emergency clinicians can find the order quickly. A bedside conversation need not follow that order. Our recommended approach is to begin with Box D and move upward: decision-maker, nutrition, medical interventions, and finally CPR. This reflects the authors’ clinical approach, not a mandatory sequence or a method proven best for every patient.
Starting with who the patient trusts can feel less abrupt than beginning with cardiac arrest. Each step then builds on the person’s priorities. If the patient raises a different concern first, follow it. The form should support the conversation rather than prevent you from hearing what matters.
Box D — Information and signatures: ask who should speak for the patient
Try, “If you were too ill to tell us what you wanted, who knows you well enough to help us understand?” Ask whether an advance directive exists and obtain it for review. Confirm the decision-maker’s authority through the appropriate process; being the closest relative does not automatically establish that authority. A patient able to make the particular decision remains central to it.
Explore the choice without turning it into a test: “Have you had a chance to tell that person what would matter to you?” Some patients have named someone but never discussed treatment preferences. Offer to help start that conversation with the patient’s permission.
Beginning with Box D does not mean obtaining a signature before the discussion. Explain that the team will review the completed choices and required signatures after the patient understands them. If family members disagree about who should decide, seek clarification rather than allowing the most vocal person to take over.
Box C — Artificially administered nutrition: hear what feeding means to the family
A question about a feeding tube can feel like a question about whether a family will continue to nourish someone they love. Begin with that concern. “What have you been told about the trouble with eating, and what are you hoping a feeding tube might help with?” Listen before explaining the options.
Discuss the purpose, potential benefits, burdens, and alternatives in the patient’s actual condition. Advanced dementia and a potentially recoverable swallowing problem require different counseling. Ask the responsible clinician to address diagnosis-specific questions, using the evidence discussed in The Hard Facts about Survival Rates.
Make the care that will continue visible. “Whatever decision you make about a tube, we still need a plan for comfort, mouth care, and feeding assistance when appropriate.” Explain oral intake in relation to the patient’s wishes, feasibility, and individualized assessment. Do not imply that declining a tube means leaving the patient without attention.
Instead of asking only, “Any additional orders?”, explore what the person intends: “Would you want us to consider a trial? What would you hope it would accomplish? If it did not help in that way, what would you want us to discuss?” Bring these answers to the clinician so that any additional orders are clear and appropriate.
Box B — Medical interventions: talk about illness before arrest
Explain that this section concerns treatment while the person still has a pulse or is breathing. Ask, “If you became much sicker, what would you most want treatment to help you do?” A patient may want more time, relief from distress, or a chance to return to a familiar activity. Avoid assuming that everyone gives those goals the same priority.
Discuss Full Treatment, Selective Treatment, and Comfort-Focused Treatment in relation to those goals. Use understandable examples involving hospitalization, breathing support, and recovery, but have the responsible clinician address the likely benefits for this patient. Avoid presenting the options as “everything” versus “nothing.”
Clarify that comfort measures belong in every category. DNR can coexist with Full Treatment before arrest. Comfort-Focused Treatment does not automatically mean hospice enrollment or prohibit transfer when another setting is needed for comfort.[2] A family’s relief at hearing these distinctions can open a more thoughtful discussion.
If a patient says, “I never want to go back to the hospital,” ask what made the last experience difficult and what circumstances they have in mind. The answer may concern unwanted procedures, separation from family, or fear of dying alone. Document the meaning behind the statement and obtain clear orders; do not infer more than the patient intended.
Box A — CPR: explain plainly, then allow a response
Begin with understanding: “When you hear the words CPR or resuscitation, what do you picture?” Explain that Box A applies when a person has no pulse and is not breathing. Describe chest compressions, possible electrical shocks, breathing support, and the possibility of intensive care if circulation returns. Avoid graphic language intended to persuade.
Ask whether the patient would like to discuss outcome figures. Explain that restarting circulation, leaving the hospital alive, and returning to a valued level of function are different outcomes. The companion evidence article provides setting-specific data and guidance for discussing its limits.
Give the patient time before asking for a choice. If tears or fear emerge, acknowledge them rather than answering with another statistic. A response such as, “This is a difficult possibility to think about. What part worries you most?” may tell you what the patient needs next.
Explain DNR directly and neutrally. The phrase “Allow Natural Death” should not be used to make one choice sound morally preferable. The goal is an informed decision consistent with the patient’s values, not a particular code status.[1]
Bring the choices back together
Review the selections as a whole. If a patient wants CPR but says they would never accept breathing support, clarify the relationship and involve the signing clinician. A mismatch may reflect an incomplete explanation, not an unreasonable patient. Do not quietly resolve it by choosing the answer you think they should have given.
Use teach-back without making the patient feel examined: “I want to check whether I explained this well. How would you describe the care you are asking for if you became very ill? And what would you want if your heart stopped?” Listen for differences between the explanation and the proposed orders.
A patient may remain uncertain. Identify what information is missing, who will provide it, and when the conversation will continue. Do not translate hesitation into consent. Follow current valid orders and clinical procedures while unresolved questions receive appropriate review.
Leave the patient with a plan, not just a signed page
Ensure that the form is completed and signed as required, accessible to the patient and relevant care teams, and consistent with current preferences. Explain where it should be kept under the agency’s process and how changes will be communicated. Patients can modify or revoke POLST; the conversation should be revisited when circumstances or wishes change.[2]
Before leaving, ask, “Is there anything in what we discussed that still feels different from what you want?” Thank the patient for explaining their priorities. Document their concerns, the decisions reached, and any follow-up needed. A good POLST conversation leaves the person feeling that the team understands them more clearly.